McMinnville vs. Newberg vs. Sherwood: How These Three Housing Markets Really Compare in 2026

By John Laney | Realtor, Newberg, Oregon | John Knows Newberg

I show homes in all three of these cities every week. They sit within about 25 minutes of each other, and buyers constantly ask me some version of the same question: “Why is Sherwood so much more expensive than McMinnville when they’re this close together?”

It’s a fair question. The answer says a lot about how the Yamhill County and Washington County markets actually work, and it matters whether you’re buying your first home, selling one, or looking for your next rental property. So let’s put the numbers side by side and talk about what they mean.

The Numbers at a Glance

Here’s how the three markets compare as of mid-2026, pulled from Redfin, Zillow, and census housing data:

	McMinnville	Newberg	Sherwood
Median sale price	~$460,000	~$517,000	~$631,000
Price per square foot	~$301	~$295	~$296
Median year built	1990	1991	1997

Look at that middle row for a second, because it surprises most people. The price per square foot in all three cities is nearly identical — right around $295 to $300. McMinnville actually edges out the other two.

So why does the median Sherwood home sell for roughly $170,000 more than the median McMinnville home? Simple: the houses are bigger and newer. Sherwood built most of its housing stock during the 1990s and 2000s boom, when the standard new home was a 2,500+ square foot two-story in a master-planned neighborhood. McMinnville and Newberg have older cores with smaller footprints mixed in, which pulls their medians down even though the land and the demand are strong.

For sellers, that’s a useful reframe. Your Newberg home isn’t “worth less” than a Sherwood home on a per-foot basis. It’s essentially the same market rate — you just may be selling fewer square feet.

McMinnville: The County Seat with the Best Downtown in the Valley

McMinnville is the biggest of the three cities and the seat of Yamhill County. Its downtown — Third Street — is the kind of main street other towns try to recreate and can’t. Historic storefronts, restaurants, tasting rooms, and actual foot traffic on a Tuesday night. Add Linfield University, the Evergreen Aviation & Space Museum (home of the Spruce Goose), and its position in the heart of Oregon wine country, and you get a town with a real identity.

From a market standpoint, McMinnville is the value play of the three. A median around $460,000 buys you more house here than anywhere else on this list, and prices softened over the past year, which has given buyers a bit of breathing room they haven’t had in a while. For investors, McMinnville’s mix of a college population, a hospital, and county employment makes for steady rental demand at a lower entry point than Sherwood.

The trade-off is the commute. McMinnville is the farthest of the three from Portland, and Highway 99W can test your patience. People who live in McMinnville tend to work in McMinnville — which, honestly, is part of why the town feels so complete.

Newberg: Wine Country’s Front Door

I live here, I invest here, and I built my business here, so I’ll admit my bias up front. But the numbers back me up.

Newberg sits at the entrance to the Chehalem Valley, about 45 minutes from Portland, and the Newberg-Dundee bypass has made that drive meaningfully better than it used to be. We’ve got George Fox University, a walkable downtown that keeps improving, and more development activity than any comparably sized town in the area — the Riverfront Master Plan, the Riverrun subdivision, and the HIVE project among them. I’ve written about all three, and they’re the reason I tell people Newberg’s next ten years look different from its last ten.

At a median around $517,000, Newberg sits squarely between its neighbors — more expensive than McMinnville, meaningfully cheaper than Sherwood. You’re paying for proximity: to Portland, to the wine industry, to the jobs in Washington County. For sellers, that middle position is an advantage. Newberg captures buyers priced out of Sherwood and Tigard who still want a real town rather than a far-out compromise.

For investors, Newberg is where I put my own money. Rental demand is consistent, the university adds a floor under it, and the development pipeline gives long-term holds a tailwind that’s hard to find at this price point.

Sherwood: The Premium Suburb

Sherwood is the outlier on price, and there are good reasons for it. It’s the only one of the three inside Washington County and the Portland metro’s urban growth boundary, which puts it 20-30 minutes from the Silicon Forest employers — Nike, Intel, and the rest. The Sherwood School District is one of the most consistently top-rated in Oregon, and families pay for that. Year after year, Sherwood lands on “safest cities in Oregon” lists.

That 1997 median year built tells the story of the housing stock: this is largely a town of newer, larger suburban homes in planned neighborhoods, with a small historic Old Town at its center. At a median around $631,000, Sherwood is a market where sellers hold a strong hand — inventory stays tight because the people who live there tend to stay.

For investors, Sherwood is a tougher entry. The numbers are harder to pencil at that purchase price, and short-term rental rules add another layer to think through (I covered Sherwood’s STR ordinance in a separate article). It can work as an appreciation play, but cash flow is a challenge.

So Which Market Is Right for You?

If I’m being blunt with you the way I am with my own clients: buy McMinnville for value and lifestyle, buy Newberg for balance and upside, buy Sherwood for schools and commute. Sell in any of them right now with confidence, because per-square-foot pricing across all three has held near $300 even through a cooler stretch of the market.

But medians are just starting points. The right answer depends on your specific street, your specific house, and your specific timeline — and that’s where local knowledge earns its keep. I work these three markets constantly, I own investment property in this area myself, and our team hosts Newberg’s only investor meetup, where conversations like this one happen every month. You can find upcoming events here: Newberg Investor Meetup on Eventbrite.

Thinking about buying, selling, or investing in McMinnville, Newberg, or Sherwood? Let’s talk through your situation — no pressure, just numbers and honest advice.

Call or text me directly:

📞 503-217-4229

Connect with John Laney | John Knows Newberg

🌐 Website: AssuranceTeamRealEstate.com 📘 Facebook: facebook.com/JohnKnowsNewberg 📸 Instagram: @JohnKnowsNewberg 💼 LinkedIn: linkedin.com/in/JohnLaneyRealtor ▶️ YouTube: Watch John’s Videos

📞 Call or text John directly: 503-217-4229 📧 [email protected]

John Laney is a licensed Oregon REALTOR® with Epique Realty / Assurance Team Real Estate, specializing in seller representation, investor properties, and commercial real estate in Newberg and the Chehalem Valley.

Contact

Main Content

A tale of three Housing Markets: Sherwood, McMinnville and Newberg